The Apple & Biscuit Show – Episode 10 (Pt.2) – The Devil is in the detail – Josh Winslade and Simon Hayes on recording live vocals for ‘Wicked’

In this episode, (Part 2 of 2), Neil and Jason talk in-depth and ‘totally technical’ to the Oscar-winning Production Sound Mixer Simon Hayes, and on set music editor Josh Winslade, about the creative decisions behind Simon’s sound recording strategy; his timing and justification for switching to digital radio mics; and the low-down on how a great relationship with the Visual Effects supervisor is so important in the quest for capturing the best possible performance from artists on set.

Pictured: Wicked Production Sound Mixer Simon Hayes (left) with On Set Music Editor Josh Winslade

About the presenters:
You can find more about Simon and his work here
Josh Winslade on IMDb
Details about Neil and Jason’s work as dialogue editors and mixers and how to contact them is here
Details of our 1-to-1, training and coaching programmes for ambitious media professionals are available at:
https://www.drneilhillman.com and https://soundproducer.com.au/coaching and www.soundformovingpictures.com

Technical notes:
Written, produced and presented by Jason Nicholas and Dr Neil Hillman – IMDb
Recorded using the CleanFeed remote recording system
Programme edited by Jason Nicholas

YouTube fair use disclaimer:
Where copyrighted material appears in episodes of The Apple and Biscuit Show, it is used under the ‘fair use’ guidelines of the Copyright Act: i.e. “Use of these clips follows Fair Use laws regarding commenting and criticizing”, where Fair Use allows for the unlicensed use of copyrighted material for purposes such as Commentary, Criticism, Parody, News reporting, Teaching, Scholarship, and Research.

In instances where copyright or credit is questioned, please contact us directly to discuss receiving credit, or removing the featured content.

Transcript:

Announcer Rosie
You’re listening to the Apple and Biscuit Show with Jason Nicholas and Dr Neil Hillman.
Neil Hillman
Welcome back to Part 2 of our Wicked technical special, with the on-set music editor Josh Winslade and the movie’s production sound mixer, Simon Hayes. If you managed to stay with us all the way through Part 1, very well done! – Because so far, this has without doubt, been one of the most detailed and comprehensive descriptions of the sound requirements for a modern musical movie, ever recorded, in a podcast… And there’s still more to come.
Jason Nicholas
In part 1 we concentrated on the playback side of things, but in this episode we’re going to hear more from Simon Hayes about the creative decisions behind his sound recording strategy; his timing and justification for switching to digital radio mics; and the low-down on how a great relationship with the Visual Effects supervisor is so important in the quest for capturing the best possible performance from artists on set. But first, we start this episode with a question that was sent in by a listener, via social media.
Neil Hillman
And this comes from Sarah or Sarah, Benchivanga, who says, “How many takes would the leads normally do? It seems like a full production day would be punishing to the voice, even for a well -trained singer. Did they do a ton of rehearsals and only a couple of singing takes?”
Simon Hayes
This is something that, and hey Sarah, it’s really nice to hear your question. This is something that comes up again and again on social media and something that I really want to address the first thing is pro singers like Cynthia and Ari know exactly how to use their voices and have continuity and stamina within their vocals and both of these artists had incredible stamina and what they won’t going to do, which I’ve seen on film sets before is blow out their vocals. They and I haven’t just seen it in live singing, I’ve seen it with actors in shouting scenes where they’ve gone a hundred percent and by take number five there that they can’t do it anymore. What both Cynthia and Ariana were fantastic at was going to ninety percent which appears as if it’s a hundred percent but means that they can do it all day long. There is no performance negative from going to 90 % versus 100%. The only difference is at 100 % you’re not going to be able to do it all day. And I’m talking about volume here, guys. I’m not talking about creative performance. I’m talking purely in terms of volume. They were both able to sing all day. But something else that I’m not sure whether this is what Sarah is getting at, but just to address other stuff that has come up on social media, no one is singing a whole song every time the camera turns. What we’re doing is we’re cutting this up in the same way as we shoot dialogue. Every time we turn over the cameras on a normal movie that isn’t live sung, we’re not having the actors play the whole scene. We’re having the actors only play the part of the scene that the camera is on the correct angle for. And so essentially, before we get into take numbers and rehearsals and stuff like that, let’s just say that every time Cynthia and Ari sung, it was only for the section of the track that the camera is on the correct angle for. So it may only be one line of singing. It may be four lines of singing. It may be eight lines of singing. But what it very, very rarely was, was a whole song. I mean, in fact, I can’t think that we ever did that for a whole song. And that’s something for people who aren’t in film. I mean, I’m not sure we’ve probably lost them by now with the amount of technical information that we’re going into here. I would imagine anyone listening at this point to this podcast is pretty immersed in film.
Neil Hillman
I would have thought so.
Simon Hayes
But, you know, we’re only capturing the appropriate piece of the song. In terms of how many takes, you know, John didn’t do lots and lots and lots of takes and he didn’t need to because Cynthia and Ari were just knocking this out the ballpark. As was Johnny Bailey, as was Jeff Goldblum and as was Michelle Yeo. You know, we didn’t really need to do a lot of takes I would guess on average the amount of takes We were doing was three or four. Would you do you think that was about right Josh?
Josh Winslade
I’d agree with that… and just to add something else to Sarah’s question, there is no version of this where rehearsals were ever for the girls singing. Like, they have sung this song by that point a hundred times They’ve done pre -records in the studios. They know it like the like the back of their hand. They’re not, those rehearsals have nothing to do with their vocals or warming themselves up or to do with their…
Simon Hayes
Let’s also say something else here, Josh. You know, the fact is we weren’t doing, the rehearsals were generally with a stand-in, a place marker so that we could get crane marks and focus marks and lighting cues, okay? When Ari or Cynthia walk onto the set or Johnny or Jeff or Michelle, guess what? Roll cameras. We’re rolling. Okay.
Josh Winslade
And maybe a rehearsal…
Simon Hayes
Not very often. Very, very rarely. No. Because John’s perspective would be what happens if there’s something magical that happens in this rehearsal, and we weren’t rolling on it. And this is another reason why the sound and music team have to be absolutely on their ‘A’-game, because we’re shooting the rehearsal and guess what’s going to happen when we cut? Get ready, go again, roll camera. So really, all of my gain e structures, all of Josh’s cues, we’ve got to have it on lockdown. There isn’t this 1980s, let’s do a rehearsal and then let’s all take three or four minutes to think about it. We’re rolling cameras and when we cut, we get the actors are in the moment okay everyone okay let’s go again you know that’s the way we shoot and that’s not just Wicked and that’s not just that’s not just live sung musicals that’s movie making now; you know we’ve got to be ready for the first rehearsal, it’s take number one… Can I ask you guys a question? Are we blowing your mind yet?
Neil Hillman
Kind of… But I just want you to know, Josh, that I am talking to you down a TotalMix RME Babyface Pro. That’s how you’re hearing me, okay? I just want you to know that I’m across this technology…
Josh Winslade
I think that you have a studio in your backpack then with that machine. It’s honestly, I have such an affinity to it because it got me through a year of filming one of the most amazing things amazing things I’ve ever been able to be a part of. It didn’t fail once.
Neil Hillman
Simon, when Jason and I were thinking about this conversation with you and Josh, obviously it sort of breaks down into two halves, because there’s the playback and there’s also the recording. So, I mean, we’ve gone quite deeply into the playback at the moment. Let’s just ask you a few questions, Simon, if we may, on the production side. So, for instance, what’s on your ISO tracks? What brand of radio mics are you using? What brand of IEMs? Can you talk about the in -ear monitors that actually were the earpieces themselves and how they were arranged so that we didn’t actually see them in the final movie?
Simon Hayes
Neil, that’s a great question. We’ve spoken a lot about Pro Tools sessions and about how they integrate with post-production, but let’s really talk about picture editing. What I’m trying to avoid wherever possible, especially at the beginning of the offline editing process in Avid, is for our fantastic editor, Myron Kirsten, to have to dip into those Pro Tools sessions. And something that I’ve developed over the years of doing musicals is I try and put the correct amount of Pro Tools stems into my sound devices Scorpio iso tracks so that my sound dailies, or rushes in UK vernacular, contain everything that Myron the picture editor and Lara his first assistant are going to require especially as they start to construct a scene from a visual perspective. What I don’t want to do is to force them into the rabbit hole of having to sync up Pro Tools sessions early. Of course, those sessions are there, their timecode locked, and they’re there for them to dip into if they need to. But what we’ve all spoken about for the Wicked workflow and on my previous films is the ability to try and streamline it so that my production sound dailies require everything that they require to construct that scene. So, I think I take seven tracks back from Josh’s Pro Tools and put them into my Iso tracks. One of those tracks is mono music and we’ll come back to that because that’s a very, very important track. So, track one is mono music, and this isn’t where they sit in my Iso tracks. When I say track one, track one is my mixed track but track one of what Josh sends to me is mono music. Track 2 is music left. Track 3 is music right. Track 4 is vocal only. Track 5 is mono timecode which as we’ve spoken about contains the music timecode. Track 6 is effects because sometimes we find effects have found their way into the music tracks especially on Rob Marshall films actually. Rob Marshall often has the sound of waves, for instance, if it’s a sea shanty embedded into his effects track. So we always have an effects track. Sometimes it’s empty, sometimes there’s nothing there, sometimes it does contain information. And there was one more track, Josh, what is that? So, we’ve done mono music,
Josh Winslade
Keyboard…
Simon Hayes
Of course! Live keyboard. Okay, so then we’ve got also the mono live keyboard which we go to should Cynthia or Ari want to leave the tempo to be able to drive the performance emotionally. What we wanted to do throughout Wicked was to give them the ability whenever possible to be able to just take a moment, lead a live keyboard specifically for really emotional parts and then we would segue back into Pro Tools playback at a specific bar number. We’ll talk more about that later but that’s our seven tracks which make their way into sound dailies. Now what I do for the picture editor is I do a mono mix on track one which is my vocal mix. Now something that both Andy Nelson the re -recording mixer who I’ve got a long relationship with and myself do, is we both treat dialogue and vocals as if they’re the same. Because why wouldn’t we? Surely one of the things that we notice about old -school musicals is that brick wall transition, in other words there isn’t a transition from dialogue on the set into lip -sync pre -recorded vocals, where you go, “Ah, there’s the lip sync and something that we don’t need to worry about at all on the live song musical is that transition because there won’t be because the person that’s speaking on the set is also going to be singing live on the set. So effectively what I’m doing is on track number one I’m doing a mix that contains the dialogue and the live sung vocals for the picture editor. What I’m not doing is embedding music into that live sung vocal because if I embed music into it at what I think is an appropriate volume then I’m basically dictating to Myron the picture editor based on what I’m hearing through my on -set headphones. I’m dictating what level the music is going to have to play under the vocal for his avid play out and what he’s cutting with and I don’t think that’s appropriate because he’s going to want to have control over that and if I do embed that music into track number one and mate it to those live sung vocals what I’m going to cause him to do is to basically become a dialogue editor and to go back into my iso tracks and reconstruct my live sung vocal tracks and if I’m weaving in and out of radio mics and booms and I know that I’m making the correct decisions as a production sound mixer number one I don’t want a picture editor to have to go back in and try and reconstruct that mix and they’re basically re-comping my vocal mix but also Myron doesn’t want to do that because he’s a picture editor and not a dialogue editor or a vocal editor and it’s not only is it not his primary skillset although he could but also it takes time away from his ability to be editing the picture. So, on track number one I’ve got my dialogue and vocal mix and on track number two is mix track two what I’ve got there is I’ve got the mono mix ISO, but instead of having it a 0 dB gain, in other words, the same gain that it’s arriving at from Pro Tools, which is on track number 27 or wherever it really inhabits on Scorpio, it will be at 0 dB gain, full range, full dynamic range. What I will do on track number two is I will reduce that. I may even be riding that volume as we’re shooting it depends and what I will be doing is is playing that at an appropriate level so that the vocal and the mono music when it is summed together creates something that is an appropriate mix for dailies, for John Chu’s headphones as we’re shooting, for everyone else’s headphones as we’re shooting but effectively when you dissect those two tracks and split them back up. You’ve got an a cappella version of the song on track number one, and you’ve got a gain adjusted mono music track on number two. That also has the added positive of when studio executives are watching dailies on their iPad or on their MacBook Pro sitting in Burbank in California. What we do is we sum those two tracks together so that instead of hearing the vocal coming out of the left speaker on their MacBook Pro and the music coming out of the right speaker on their MacBook Pro, those two tracks are summed together for daily’s play out so that what the production executives are hearing is a mono mix with an appropriate amount of music. Now, just to dive into this even deeper, most picture editor’s now are cutting in 5 .1 and if I’ve embedded that music into track number one we’ve already spoken about the fact that they can’t then subtract it but what I also want them to be able to do is when they are doing a very quick avid play out without leaving my Scorpio dailies they could they can take the stereo left and right music that I’ve got on tracks 25 -26 and create a stereo version for my dailies without going anywhere near Josh’s Pro Tools session. They can create that stereo cut in their Avid, but then when they get that cut into a position where they quite like to show Mark Platt and John Chu, they can then, at that point, timecode lock, at that point, much later on down the line, they can go into Josh’s Pro Tools session and add the 5 .1 music to my Track 1 vocal.
Josh Winslade
And just to add as well, because I think this is really important, that mono music ISO, that feed that I send Simon, is automated to when we are live, when we are not live as well. So essentially, what Simon is able to give the director, the executive, the producers on that show, the next day with their daily rushes is something that you can actually sit down and watch and not really tell when it’s live or pre -record or because he’s done that blend as the production sound mixer, he has mixed that for them to a point where sometimes I couldn’t even hear it. And that doesn’t even as far as the editors and needing to do that. That just goes to the post house that handles all the rushes. They sum those two tracks. Next day, in the daily’s, the rushes, that’s there. Ready for execs, John, Ari, Cynthia, to sit down, watch and see those takes without, “Oh, we went live here and oh, there’s nothing on this track and oh, now it’s pre-recorded.” No, that’s not the experience at all. It’s rough, it’s not perfect, but it is very, very, very watchable and very kind of linear. You’re not pulled out of it.
Simon Hayes
Now, I think someone asked on social media when we put out for this podcast questions, I think someone asked, “What do I listen to?” And that’s a really interesting question which I’d like to answer. That goes back to both me and Andy Nelson treating the live sung vocal as if it’s dialogue, what I try and listen to is a cappella. What I try and do, what I have to do on the first take, as I’ve just said, the first take is our rehearsal, I will, on that first take as long as the music doesn’t need manipulating, if I think that it’s going to, that one specific set level will be appropriate for this scene. I will set that music level on take number one and I will you know I will set that the vocal level and the music level against each other and that will give me that will stay the same through the whole scene so that I get so that there’s audio continuity as Myron the picture editor is cutting the scene so that the gain levels aren’t jumping around all over the place again because I don’t want him to have to worry about audio. I want him to just be completely immersed in the pictures and the creative process rather than worrying about audio levels or audio ISOs. So that first take, I’ll set those gain levels and hopefully be able to leave them there. And then on take number two, if I’m happy, I’ll have a quick playback for 10, 15 seconds in between take number one and take number two and go, “Right, okay, that’s good. “That sounds great. “That’s the appropriate level for Myron. And then for the rest of the takes, as long as this isn’t a massive dynamic gain swing and I don’t have to be riding the gain on the music, I’ll leave that alone and I won’t listen to it. I’ll go back and I’ll listen to these vocals a cappella. Why am I doing that? For a number of reasons. One, because I want to listen to the vocals as if they’re dialogue, I want to hear everything. And the problem with listening to the music at all times is it disguises all sorts of issues that I may be having. The music could be disguising clothing rustle issues that are lower down in the in the gain structure than the music is sitting at. And if I’m listening a cappella, I can be working with Arthur so that in between takes he can do a micro adjustment on a lav to reduce that clothing rustle if required. Also, if I’ve got music playing on all of those live vocals, I’m not going to hear, if I don’t know, if craft services have just turned on a noisy generator. That music will basically disguise problems that I should be as a production sound mix of solving immediately. What else would the music hide? It will hide footsteps. Taz, someone there has got a really set of noisy shoes. Can we get in there and put some felt on the bottom of their shoes or is that person really in frame? Could we put some carpet under them? All of these indiscretions will be masked if I’m listening to music whereas if I treat this vocal as if it’s dialogue on a normal movie then I can continue doing the job that I would normally do on a movie set which is making sure that voices and performances I’m recording are absolutely as clean as possible for Nancy Nugent-Title and sound post.
Jason Nicholas
Simon, speaking of the distribution of tracks, did you get to use your Nagra on Wicked, like you did in the Bond film?
Simon Hayes
I didn’t. And you know what? I really, really love my Niagara, Jason, but it’s, but it’s something, it’s something that I love to look at in my living room. It’s not something that I ever want to use again on a film set to be completely frank with you.
Jason Nicholas
It does lack the necessary Dante integration, I suppose…
Neil Hillman
Very good. Okay, so Simon, one of the burning questions we’ve had expressed to us by the listener concerns radio mic brands and what it was that you used on Wicked. What can you tell us about what was, I believe, something of a journey for you…
Simon Hayes
Oh, this is something that we haven’t really discussed in any of my interviews and podcasts. And you know what, Neil, Jason, thank you for giving us the opportunity to come on to the Apple and Biscuit Show and do this technical breakdown. Because I think that having listened to everything that we’ve spoken about so far, we really haven’t gone into this much detail about the technical aspect of Wicked on any interviews that I’ve done, on any other podcasts that I’ve done. And what I think is really exciting about this is we’re giving a roadmap to other production sound mixers, perhaps younger production sound mixers who are going to be faced with these challenges sometime later on in their career. We’re giving them a kind of roadmap to start how to how to apply their thought process to the technical challenges. So, radio mic brands, you know, I always speak a lot about DPA labs, but very rarely about what we were doing with the transmitters and receivers. And the first thing that I want to say about that is that Wicked was a very, very long project. It was 155 days of shooting. There was an awful lot of prep there and in the middle of all of it we had a little break for the actors strike which we all had to observe and so we need to rewind quite a number of years to me putting this kit together for Wicked and making sure that I was going to be providing the correct kit for the job that I could guarantee was going to be rock solid and reliable because the primary thing here, especially when we’re talking about radio mics, is the fact that we need reliability. And an analogy that I’d like to give to the listeners here is we don’t see Formula One testing Tesla engines. We are not going to use the absolute top end of motorsport as a test bed for a new form of engine. And it was exactly the same on Wicked. I knew that fully digital radio mics had just been released as I started putting Wicked together. And I kind of thought about whether I should move on to them, but there was two problems. The first problem was I didn’t want to use Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande singing live as a test for digital radio mics. I wanted to know that I had absolute reliability. I wanted to know where my gain structures were. I wanted to use something that I knew was going to do 12 hours on set every day five or six days a week and when I would need to change batteries where my levels would be and so for that reason I started Wicked on the exact radio mics which have held me in such great stead for a number of years which is the Lectrosonic system. The analogue Lectrosonic system It’s actually called a digital hybrid. The signal itself is in the digital domain within the transmitter, but it goes back into the analogue domain for the transmission and reception. And it’s a really, really great system. It’s, we use the SMB transmitters, which are tiny, very, very lightweight. We can change the power levels to the appropriate requirement for depending on how far away our sharks fins are. And I know exactly what those radio transmitters sound like with DPA lavs and they sound fantastic. So, although I toyed with moving on to a newer system, I decided that this wasn’t a film to test something on. But as we were shooting, there were other sound mixers who were on smaller films testing the new digital system. And so, as we went through months and months of shooting on Wicked, I was watching very carefully the sound groups in the forums and talking to colleagues about their experiences with newer digital systems and starting to formulate a plan. One of the other reasons why I didn’t want to move on to the digital system and I’m going to get into specifics now. The digital system that I was looking at the start of Wicked was the Sound Devices Stripe Audio Limited A10 system and something that I knew wasn’t going to be good enough for Wicked was the size of the A10 transmitters. They were just too big and I was actually getting really positive reports about how they sounded but there were a few teething issues not least the size and not least the fact that I knew that where I needed to put one of the primary transmitters on Wicked was in Cynthia’s hat and an A10 transmitter was too big too bulky and would have made that hat way too much and so that was another big big reason why I stayed with the SNB with the electronics. Because when we’re talking about sound quality differences, we’re talking up in single digit percentages. We’re not talking about massive night and day differences in sound quality. It’s minimal. I’ve spoken lots about how I want every single percentage and marginal gains, but not if that’s at the expense of an actress saying to me, “Simon, why am I using this big pack? It’s much bigger than what I’ve used on my previous film.” Or even worse, an actress saying to me, “Simon, this hat weighs too much with this transmitter in it. We’re going to have to do something about this.” So we started on the Lectrosonics and they sounded absolutely fantastic. As I said, I know where the gain structures are, and they just provide excellent clarity and an excellent signal to noise ratio. But when we had a break for the actor’s strike, at that point two things that had happened. The first thing that had happened was sound devices had brought out the new A20 mini packs, and suddenly I’ve got something that’s as small as Lectrosonic’s SMB. The other thing that had happened was we would probably, you know, 100 days into our shoot and during that time other sound mixers had been using the new sound devices system on a bunch of other movies. There had been software updates done based on what those sound mixers had found, the bugs had been ironed out and, you know, during that time other sound mixers had basically worked alongside sound devices to get these radio mics into what I considered to be a reliable enough state for me to put them onto Ariana and Cynthia singing live. And so actually during that actor strike I completely rethought my radio mic situation. So, we came back after the actors strike onto Wicked, for the last portion of the shoot, with a completely redesigned radio mic system. We had moved onto 16 A20 minis, we had moved onto a Nexus receiver, we had off -boarded that Nexus receiver and put it on a Zooka cart, we had it then tied back to my production sound cart, because of course Nexus and A20s work in a different way, we’re not using 50 to 100 milliwatts in the way we are with an analogue system, we’re trying to transmit on two milliwatts because that is the way that we get more battery life. And so, we really had to treat digital radio mics in a completely different manner. And you know what guys, looking back, I’m really, really pleased about the way this played out. Josh speaks earlier in the podcast about Robin and the receiver rack that he built that was off -board, that we were able to place 50 foot up in the air above Shiz University, and get coverage across four football fields. Frankly, I don’t think that that was the correct environment to be testing Sound Devices A20s on digital. I don’t think we would have got the same amount of coverage. I think that we would have been absolutely fine with Sound Devices because we would have been able to re-record off their microSD cards. But I actually think for that specific location, Lectrosonics gave us the coverage that we needed and I don’t think that any digital radio mic brand would have given us the same amount of range as the Lectrosonics Venue SMB system did. However, when we came back from the strike and we were onto smaller sets, I think that I got a tangible increase in sound quality by moving onto the Sound Devices A20 system. We dropped down to two milliwatts. We had the shark’s fins on the set with Arthur and Robin Johnson, my two first ASs. And they had an iPad on the set that they could manipulate Nexus with. I had an iPad back on my cart, which could manipulate Nexus. we created our own private Wi-Fi network to be able to run Nexus and the A20s. And by the way, a big shout out to Chris Munro [Production Sound Mixer], a colleague of mine who was so open in the way that he shared information about his experiences with sound devices and Nexus. We went into this knowing exactly how he had got the best out of Nexus and Sound Devices on Mission Impossible and we basically took the lead from him on how to apply these digital radio mics, which I strongly believe are best off -boarded at all times and then tied back to the production sound cut, which is obviously completely different to the way we ran Lectrosonics. Effectively, by the time we got to Defying Gravity, which is Cynthia flying through the air on wires singing Defying Gravity with, as you know guys, a huge amount of gain and the highest SPL that I’ve ever recorded in a sung vocal we were on the A20 system and what was lovely about that was I had gained forward so in other words I didn’t need to set an appropriate transmitter gain level I could pull that gain level from my CL16 mixer back on the sound cart and basically I had a chunky 24 -bit digital signal to be able to really continue and not compress any of Cynthia’s wonderful dynamic range. When she sang Defying Gravity, that was completely and utterly in the digital domain.
Neil Hillman
Now what about the tricky In Ear Monitoring arrangements for the artists? Obviously both Cynthia and Ariana have experience of using concert quality IEMs when they perform, so how did you manage to combine ensuring the technical quality with the challenge of the artists being shot in close-up and potentially, the IEM’s needing to be painted out?
Simon Hayes
We’ve been working with a company called PureTone who are based in the UK and specifically one of the top guys there called Deke Freaky and he has been working with us since I started doing musicals and what he provides is just an incredible personal service. So, the first thing that Deke can do for us is he custom moulds all of our IEMs and earwigs to the specific actors that are going to be wearing them. Now that’s important for a bunch of reasons. One of the reasons is because if an IEM can sit right inside the ear canal or an earwig right inside the ear canal, it’s going to protrude less from the ear, which is going to require less of a paint out. We’ll come back to the VFX paint out in a moment. But the other thing is, when actors, for instance, let’s let’s think about Ari, she’s swinging on chandeliers as she sings Popular. Let’s think about Cynthia. She’s doing loop the loops as she sings Defying Gravity at high speed. If those IEMs are not custom fit and designed for the specific actor’s ear canal, they’re going to come flying out and we’re going to lose time, we’re going to lose their performance, it’s just not acceptable at all. So, we always get the IEMs and the earwigs custom fitted to our cast. And what happens is Deke and Arthur and Maggie Rodford, our fantastic music supervisor, set up a protocol in prep where perhaps actors are coming in for costume fittings and after their costume fitting, they’re going and meeting Deke and an audiologist who’s doing a quick cast of their ear canal. That becomes a CAD file and that then gives them the information to build specific and personal IEMs and earwigs. And what we actually did on Wicked for all of the main cast, so Johnny, Jeff, Michelle, Cynthia, Ari, they all had IEMs that were cabled, and they had earwigs and the reason for that is this – one of the things that I knew was going to be different about Wicked in comparison to the other musicals that I’ve done that are completely sung live was we were not always going to be playing just a mid-range keyboard into their earwigs. I knew that Greg Wells had produced these backing tracks. I know that Greg is known for his rhythm section. And when we listened to these backing tracks, they were beautiful. They were detailed. They had really high top end. You know, the high hats sounded beautiful, but also the bass, the sub bass, you know, the bass guitar, everything about the rhythm section was just incredible. But I knew that it was going to confuse the hell out of some earwigs which really are only good from about 350 hertz up to I don’t know two or three kilohertz that you know it’s a very mid-range sound you get from earwigs. So I knew that earwigs wouldn’t do justice to Greg Wells backing tracks but secondarily I also knew that both Cynthia and Ari are used to having proper IEM support when they’re singing because they also work in different industries where you don’t have to worry about what we see in shot. And so, what I wanted to do was to be able to provide a full range solution to them. The last thing I wanted when these actors arrived on set was having them say hey you know this sounds tinny why can I have a bit more bass and the other thing that earwigs don’t really like you can do it but they don’t really like it is putting vocal back into them. With earwigs, the best way of getting them to sound good is to just put a mid -range signal with no vocal through them, which if you’re doing a live song musical that’s only accompanied by a live keyboard, they’re great. But if you’re doing a live song musical where the actor wants to hear their own personal vocal mix with their own amount of reverb. and a Greg Wells backing track that’s incredibly detailed and bass heavy they’re just not going to be appropriate and so what we did was when we had scenes where one of our actors just needed a segue into a bit of music for some choreography or just needed to hear some music for some timing we would give them an earwig so there wasn’t a paint out because an earwig has no cable and so it’s absolutely perfect for VFX. There won’t be any VFX work needed. However, the moment they were actually going to sing live, they were given full range IEMs and those required cables coming out of their ears down into a Sennheiser-EW IEM pack. And each one of those actors was given their own choice of vocal mix. In other words, they could choose their own reverb setting. Ari had a specific reverb setting she liked on her vocal, Cynthia had a different reverb setting and that was always a starting point on every track. Obviously, every track Josh created a specific tone in their personal mix, and this is why Josh wasn’t just a music editor, he was effectively doing the same job as a front -of -house mixer as well, creating a whole bunch of different personal IEM mixes on the set for these actors, something that I didn’t want to get involved in, I didn’t want to have this technical hurdle in front of me that was going to have no impact on what I’m producing for the final product. I want to be immersed in the creative side of decision -making on the movie set and I wanted someone else to be able to support the actors, which of course is incredibly important, but I didn’t want it to be one of my responsibilities because it was something that would take my mind off the true priority, what needed to be the priority, which is how to record the very, very best tracks on Wicked that we’re going to be hearing in the cinema. So, Josh would do that with Ari and Cynthia. he would have a starting point on where they like their reverb and then on each track before they started singing before we shot that first rehearsal Arthur Fenn would be with the actor and saying okay listen let’s just give us a level let’s hear you sing and Josh would be turning up either their radio mic or their boom depending on what was going to be our primary vocal acquisition microphone, and setting a level up against the music that was personal to them. Starting off with that, what we know is their global starting point of where they like their reverb to be, and perhaps adjusting that track to track, and obviously then saying how loud would you like the other person in the scene to be in your ear. So that’s something else that was happening on a day -to -day basis. There’s been lots of questions in social media about how we hid those IEMs. We got the IEMs manufactured not just to the actor’s ear canal but also, we had the match to the skin tone colour. And what that meant was it didn’t mean that they were invisible, but it meant that on a wide shot they wouldn’t need painting out because for instance Cynthia’s were green and they were and they were coloured the exact same colour green as Frances Hannan’s fantastic makeup that she designed for Elphaba. And Ari’s IEM was the exact same colour as Galinda’s makeup on her face. You know, this is a something that we colour matched with Deke, right from the manufacturing process by collaborating with Makeup, and Francis and her team, to make sure that we could get these skin tones matched as well as possible, so that on wide shots, Pablo Hellman, the FX supervisor, wouldn’t be having to worry about paint out. And then what we did with the cables, we also had the cables made an appropriate colour for the hair, for the skin tone. We had a whole bunch of different cables and those cables we would hide as much as we possibly could. And I’m not saying that they were invisible, but again, if they were disguised as well as possible under hair for wide shots, it meant that Pablo wasn’t going to have to start painting them out of wide shots. But in close-ups, we very much had Pablo’s support and his whole team in VFX’s support. And I can’t thank them enough where there was an agreement made that they would remove all of them digitally imposed in VFX.
Jason Nicholas
This is a great point to make, Simon, because the sound department can be helped so much, can’t they, by a director who understands that now VFX can easily and inexpensively, that’s the key thing, paint out a boom that absolutely needs to be in shot or remove a lav mic that needs to be on top of a certain costume. And while we’re talking about capturing the best performance from an actor, that level of cooperation between the sound department and VFX can be crucial, can it?
Simon Hayes
There’s a couple of things that are really important that I want to say about that. VFX is absolutely one of the best ways that we can support performances in movies nowadays. Not only are the VFX department able to create immersive structures visually on set and build worlds for us visually and support production design and set design but they’re also able to help us preserve original performances by removing booms on some shots, removing lavs on other shots, and on Wicked from removing IEMs. Now when I say that they preserved original performances, there’s a really big question here… Would Ari and Cynthia have been able to immerse themselves so deeply in the music if they didn’t have that acoustic support that we were able to give them. Because 15 years ago we wouldn’t have been able, it wouldn’t have been cost-effective to paint these IEMs out, but now it is cost-effective and what do cinema audiences, what do directors, what do actors get out of that ability for VFX to be able to support our industry is we can present better performances because our actors are better supported acoustically when they’re singing live and also not just that. When we’re talking about microphones obviously, we try not to put microphones in shot we try to keep booms out of shot we try to keep lavs out of shot, but on Wicked there were moments where I was able to say to Pablo, particularly on some of Ari’s dresses, and in fact Cynthia when I think about it, you know there was a whole section where she wasn’t wearing her hat at the Wizard’s, and where we had a lav on the outside of Cynthia’s costume. Ari had lavs on the outside of her costume a lot in Wicked and they were removed off afterwards digitally. The way of thinking about this for your listeners is this a microphone removal in VFX and ADR both have a cost implication, but only one of them has a creative implication. If we have to ADR a scene, not only is it costing us money, but it’s potentially costing us performance as well. If we only have to remove the microphone in VFX, it’s just costing us money. It’s not costing us the performance. And that’s why it’s always worth nowadays considering both of those issues because every year the ability for VFX to actually remove a microphone and it’s not even a paint out now, often it’s just a pixel replacement which isn’t a really intricate process. It can be extremely cost effective to do that and we’re saving those magical original performances and so that’s one of the reasons why I think that it’s important for us as an industry to keep up to date on what can be done, not just from a dialogue editing plugins perspective, but also as production sound mixers from a VFX perspective. If that radio mic, if that lav is going to cause ADR because it’s rustling with a costume and nothing can be done without putting it in shot, is it worth that conversation with the VFX supervisor? One of the reasons why Pablo was so open to this as well, with microphone removal and with IEM removal is because in his spare time Pablo’s a musician and so he gets it. He understood that Ariana and Cynthia needed that acoustic support, and he also understood that if I was saying Pablo that laugh sounds terrible under all of those beautiful ruffles on Galinda’s costume. Can I just get it onto the outside. He was able to say, “Yep, no problem, we can remove that in post.”
Neil Hillman
Simon, there have been times when I’ve been mixing both on location and in the mixing theatre when I can feel a huge surge of emotion that I can barely contain. Sometimes it’s the way that I gaze gauge if I’ve hit the mark with what I’m trying to achieve with a soundtrack. So do you ever find yourself getting emotionally involved with the narrative or the character that you’re recording?
Simon Hayes
I find myself emotionally involved on a lot of movies and it’s whenever there’s a performance that I completely and utterly believe. And that happens luckily a lot. Whenever I’m watching those monitors on my sound card and I feel like I’m sitting in a cinema rather than at a sound card, that’s when I know that potentially we’re making something special. And that happened a lot on Wicked, but Wicked had an added advantage and that is music. When we get into music and live singing, there’s something that really does pull the heartstrings, just you know it’s something that happened a lot on Les Misérables and again happened a lot on Wicked where I just felt immersed in emotion and something that we’ve got on a movie set that we don’t have when we go to the theatres, we’ve got close-ups. So, we have the live singing, and we have the music when we’re in the theatre, but when we’re in a cinema we also have close-ups. So, it’s almost like a double whammy, it’s a perfect storm of emotion because we can see the actors’ eyes, we can see their facial expressions, we’re right in there with them and we can feel their voice, their emotion, the way that they’re breathing. And that’s one of the things that I think Live Vocals really does bring to a film. It just supports that emotional element that sometimes a studio pre -record just doesn’t have because when you can hear those subtle nuances of the actor’s breathing patterns that are in sync with the way that they’re walking or moving around a set. We just buy it, we trust it, we don’t question it because it’s real.
Jason Nicholas
Simon, we’ve got one final question here, but I just have to interject before this question and say that as far as audio is concerned, I think you are truly the wizard of Oz.Simon Hayes
I love you for that, Jason…
Neil Hillman
Have you been preparing that all evening?
Jason Nicholas
I have not actually, I just thought of that, but I had to take the opportunity because it’s there. This final question, I’m not sure who this is from, it’s just signed ‘from Neil’. It says, “As a sound professional of many years standing, I have always used the quality of a production’s catering as the true benchmark for the films I’ve worked on. How did the food rate on Wicked?
Simon Hayes
You know what, you’re going to have to have to ask Josh that question and I’ll tell you why; I’m really careful with my diet, and you’ll genuinely find me eating, you know, chicken and salad. That’s, you know, as I’ve got older, that’s how I keep myself in shape. You know, I try to keep myself in good shape so that I can continue to deliver on these movies. And one of the ways I do that is by being very careful about my diet. Josh, what was the catering like on Wicked?
Josh Winslade
It was good. Yeah, no, they did a good job. Yeah, that is quite funny. I think Simon’s almost as passionate about his body and his health as he is about sound, almost as passionate. So, yeah. No, the catering was good. It got us through the day. It gave us the strength we needed to get through and stuff. So, yeah, you can’t really fault it. It’s free. who can complain about free food?
Neil Hillman
Excellent. As a sound professional, me, never. Simon, Josh, thank you so much for sharing your onset experiences from Wicked and your generosity in sharing your knowledge. We all really, and when I say all, I mean the whole of us in the sound community, we really appreciate it.
Simon Hayes
Thank you. Can I just, just before we go, can I just add one thing guys? Can I just say that what I’d like to do is to just elevate outsiders and other departments perspective on production sound. Too long we’ve been seen as technical support networks that sit outside the set and only complain when we need one more take. We are creative collaborators with directors, and we need to shout that from the rooftops. It’s really, really important. Sound is not sound, sound is performance. Every single nuance of the original performance is what we’re recording. And the more we can elevate production sound, the easier it’s going to be to support those original performances and the better the films are that we’re all going to make.
Neil Hillman
Here, here.
Simon Hayes
Guys, thanks so much for giving so much of your time, Jason and Neil. I really appreciate it because I’m conscious that these a longer podcast that you give me than you’ve given anyone else. And I just want to thank you for that because I know that, you know, none of us are getting paid here. And I just really, really heartfelt, thank you very much.
Neil Hillman
Well, you’re very welcome, Simon, and I have to say that we’re incredibly grateful for yours and Josh’s time to talk with us today, and for so freely sharing your knowledge with the sound, and wider, filmmaking community. And also, thanks for the way that you’ve been so supportive to me and Jason, in what we’re trying to do – and the people we’re trying to reach – with The Apple and Biscuit Show podcast. I think we’re all on a similar path, which is to raise awareness and change the attitude towards sound, elevating it in people’s understanding, so that more come to see the powerful creative force that sound can be, not just as sound for moving pictures, but in everyday life as well. Ah, yes, and one last thing, of course: when does work start on the Wicked Part 2 movie?
Simon Hayes
We’ve shot Wicked part two, but it hasn’t been through sound post. Wicked part two is pretty much locked from an editing, from a picture editing perspective. Sound post is playing around and they’re starting in earnest in the next couple of weeks. And then it will be released on, I think, November the 25th, 2025. So, we shot two movies in one, basically.
Jason Nicholas
And that brings to an end our two-part special on the movie Wicked, with on-set music editor Josh Winslade and the film’s production sound mixer Simon Hayes. Part one of the Wicked special, and indeed all of our previous episodes of the Apple and Biscuit Show are available on your favourite podcast platform, such as Apple Podcasts, Spotify or Amazon Music. Also be sure to follow us on Instagram at Apple and Biscuit Show.
Neil Hillman
Contact details for Jason and me in our day jobs as dialogue editors and mixers-for-hire are on today’s show page, as well as links to my books and our 1-to-1 training and coaching services for professionals looking to take their sound skills to the next level; whether that’s as a developing sound professional, or maybe you’re a picture editor or film director looking to better understand and unleash the full emotional power of a well thought-out soundtrack. Whichever you are, you’ll be made most welcome, and it will be our pleasure to help you on your journey to discover the hidden magic of sound. Thanks for listening.
Announcer Rosie
The Apple and Biscuit Show is written, produced, and presented by Jason Nicholas and Dr Neil Hillman. It is edited and mixed by Jason Nicholas in our Sydney studio.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ten + nineteen =

Scroll to Top